Country Cheese and More


Showing all 3 results

Most of our 50+ varieties of cheese come directly from factories in Wisconsin, the dairy and cheese capital of America. Our cheese products evolve with newly created cheeses and based upon customer demand. New cheese flavors are introduced all the time and enjoy displaying our favorites for you here.

While our main cheese producers are from Wisconsin we often call on our Amish friends from Holmes county, Ohio, home of America’s largest Amish settlement to additional varieties of the midwest’s best.

Please note: During warmer weather, cheese must be shipped overnight. Please call to speak with one of team members before placing an order. We want to make sure you get your cheese and can enjoy it.

Amish Sampler

Amish Sampler

Amish Sampler 1 Loaf of our famous fresh bread, 8 oz. of our homemade Amish Peanut Butter, 9 oz. Apple [...]

Add to cart

Gourmet Choice Cheese Sampler

Gourmet Choice Approximately 3 lbs. of our delicious mid-western cheese, including Colby, Amish Style Swiss, Cojack and Havarti Cheeses.  This [...]

Add to cart

Ultimate Farmers Choice Gift Basket

The Ultimate Farmer’s Choice Gift Basket includes a wide variety of Arthur’s Amish products.  This is one of our best [...]

Add to cart