Country Cheese and More

Baked Goods

Showing all 7 results

Along with gourmet cheeses hand picked across the midwest we also run a full time Amish bakery out of our shop. Check out our products and fall in love with the “and More” In Country Cheese and More.

Cake Pop Bouquet

We are now offering our best-selling cake pops for the holiday season! 1 dozen Cake Pops (Your Choice of Cake [...]

Add to cart

Amish Noodles

Bring a piece of Amish Country to your families meals with our homemade Amish Noodles. (Flour, egg, yolks, water, yellow [...]

Add to cart

Sticky Pecan Rolls

A Country Cheese and More fan favorite…The Sticky Pecan Roll. Made with flour, yeast, milk, sugar, salt, eggs, pecans, caramel, [...]

Add to cart

Cinnamon Rolls

Five delicious boundaries stand between you and the holy grail of cinnamon rolls, the middle. Starting at $5.25 our cinnamon [...]

Add to cart

Fudge (1 LB.)

Made right here in the heart of Illinois Amish Country, Country Cheese and More is proud to present freshly made [...]

Select options

Freshly Baked Cookies

Country Cheese and More bakes some of the best Amish style cookies around and you can order yours 6 at [...]

Select options

Bakers Choice Gift Basket

Baker’s Choice Gift Basket 1 Loaf Honey Wheat Bread, 1 Pan Cinnamon Rolls, 1 Small Loaf Rhubarb Nut Bread, 1/2 [...]

Add to cart